NYC Thanksgiving Dinner Costs Hit $184.43, Up 15% in a Year
A Thanksgiving feast in New York now costs $184.43, up 15% year over year, with turkey up 17% and apple cider up 75% after a freeze hit New York's apple harvest.
A Thanksgiving dinner for New Yorkers now costs $184.43, up 15% from last year, according to the New York Post's survey of 18 holiday staples at six grocery chains across the five boroughs.
The centerpiece of the table drove much of the sticker shock. A 20-pound Bell & Evans young turkey at Morton Williams, a popular regional chain, now runs $79.80, a 17% increase over 2025. "The meat is outrageous," said Carole Miller, 89, shopping at the Morton Williams on Bleecker Street in Greenwich Village. "There's almost so much pork you can eat."
What does this change for grocery operators?
The sharpest single increase landed on apple cider, which rocketed 75%, from $3.99 to $6.99. The cause sits upstream in sourcing: a spring freeze devastated the apple harvest in upstate and western New York, and growers have reported an estimated $30 million in losses so far in 2026, according to the governor's office. For retailers, that means constrained supply and higher cost of goods on a seasonal item with fixed demand.
Whole milk soared 50%, with a half-gallon of Farmland brand rising from $5.99 to $8.99. Libby's 100% pure pumpkin jumped 43% to $4.29. A nine-inch pumpkin pie at Whole Foods locations across the city climbed from as low as $11.75 last year to $13.99 this year, a 19% increase.
Not every item moved. Prices for at least eight products in the survey held flat year over year. Only Idahoan boxed mashed potatoes fell — down 50 cents, a 10% decrease.
New York carries the country's highest holiday dinner bill
The American Farm Bureau puts the average turkey price nationwide up 30% this year, to $1.76 per pound. That is nearly 88% above the 94 cents per pound average recorded in 2024, a two-year run of double-digit inflation at the meat case.
New York leads the country in per-person Thanksgiving dinner cost, the Farm Bureau reported — 20% above the national average and 9% higher than neighboring Northeastern states.
For fixed-income households, the arithmetic is tight. "The milk, the bread, the fruits, meats all went up," said Angelo Hernandez, 66, a retired industrial mechanic shopping at the Union Square Whole Foods. "It's hard, especially if you're retired. If you're working, you have an income every week. Now, if you're retired, it's once a month."
Hernandez said he and his wife are relying on family to absorb the biggest-ticket item. "My son gets the turkey — he works so he buys it," he said.
Demand, so far, is holding. Shoppers like Miller said the price tags will not keep them from the traditional table. "I'm gonna buy it regardless of what the price is," she said with a laugh.
Whether that holds into December will depend on whether dairy, baking and produce costs ease after the holiday — and whether grocers keep passing them through or start engineering promotions to protect volume.
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.
718 articles


