Regulation & Food Safety

72% of UK supermarket products would fail updated nutrient model

An Oxford study of 15,514 products finds 72% would fail the updated nutrient profiling model, with soft drinks' pass rate collapsing from 66% to 6%.

Cereals, soft drinks hit hardest by UK nutrient rule change – study
Cereals, soft drinks hit hardest by UK nutrient rule change – study — Concord90 / pixabay

Nearly three-quarters of UK supermarket food and drink products — 72% of 15,514 items analysed — would fail the government's nutrient test under proposed updates, up from 58% under the current model. That's the headline finding of a University of Oxford study evaluating changes to the UK's nutrient profiling model (NPM), first proposed in 2018 and published by the government in January.

The NPM matters commercially because it decides which products count as high in fat, sugar or salt — the HFSS label. Ofcom, the UK broadcast regulator, uses the model to enforce restrictions on advertising HFSS products. A failing score can therefore shut a product out of televised marketing entirely.

What changes under the revised model?

Of the 2,498 products that switched classification, 93% moved from a pass to a fail — meaning reformulation, not just marketing, becomes the pressure point for suppliers. The study attributes the shift to two mechanical changes: "Replacing total sugars with free sugars, together with stricter scoring thresholds, meant many of the products scored more points for sugar under the new model," the researchers wrote.

Free sugars exclude those naturally present in fruit and dairy, so products relying on intrinsic sweetness gain no credit under the revised scoring.

Which categories take the hit?

The pass-rate collapses are uneven, and that's where menu and range planning gets concrete:

  • Soft drinks: pass rate falls from 66.2% to 5.9% — the sharpest drop in the study
  • Breakfast cereals: from 79% to 39%
  • Yoghurts: from 77.8% to 36%
  • Pizzas: from 50.7% to 28.9%

Confectionery, cakes and processed potatoes were relatively unchanged — they were already failing in large numbers.

The revised model does offer one offset: it raises the maximum points available for fibre, which partially cushions categories like breakfast cereals and savoury snacks. In practice, that rewards fibre fortification as a reformulation lever while sugar reduction does the heavy lifting.

What are the study's limits?

The analysis covered own-brand and branded products sold by Tesco, Sainsbury's, Asda, Ocado and Marks and Spencer. It excluded discounters such as Aldi and Lidl, and it did not cover food sold out of home — restaurants, cafés and takeaways sit outside the scope. The researchers also noted the products weren't weighted by sales or market share, so the 72% failure rate counts every item equally rather than by volume sold.

The study was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research.

What does this change for manufacturers?

The government opened a consultation in March on applying the updated model, so the clock is running for suppliers to respond. Industry reaction has already split along predictable lines. When the updated NPM was published, trade body The Food and Drink Federation said it was concerned the revisions would penalise reformulated products — companies that cut sugar in line with earlier guidance could find their reformulated recipes still failing the new test. Campaign groups, by contrast, welcomed the update.

For soft drink makers the stakes are steepest: a category where two-thirds of products currently pass would see barely one in twenty clear the bar. Expect the consultation responses to focus heavily on the free-sugar calculation and the fibre offset — the two levers that decide how many of those 15,514 products stay marketable under HFSS advertising rules.

nutrient-profiling-modelhfss-advertisingfree-sugarsproduct-reformulationofcom-restrictions

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

692 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »