64% of Holiday Shoppers Want Screen-Free Gifts, and the Calendar Is Moving Earlier

64% of consumers want screen-free gifts, 78% of Gen Z; PwC sees spending down 2% as 8 in 10 budget. Earlier calendars put homemade gifts back in play.

Now is the time to start making your holiday gifts
Now is the time to start making your holiday gifts — ronstik / pixabay

Sixty-four percent of consumers say they will prioritize screen-free gifts this holiday season, and the preference climbs to 78% among Gen Z shoppers, according to PwC's 2026 Holiday Outlook. The figure anchors a broader shift: holiday gifting is moving earlier, budgets are tightening, and homemade or personalized gifts are regaining a place on lists that online retail once dominated.

The screen-free finding is not a rejection of digital life. As digital tools embed deeper into daily routines, shoppers are looking for gifts that feel tangible, nostalgic and personal. PwC also found that 63% of Gen Z consumers say a shared meal matters more to them than a physical present. This year's nostalgia, in other words, is less about recreating the past and more about carving out offline experiences inside a highly digital season.

What does this change for holiday budgets?

PwC expects holiday gift spending to fall 2% from last year, and 8 in 10 consumers plan to use some form of budgeting strategy this season. Homemade gifts gain relevance here beyond cost alone: the time spent making them becomes part of their value, positioning the gift as an expression of familiarity rather than a catalog selection.

The shopping calendar keeps moving up

The timing data is consistent across surveys:

  • 2 in 5 consumers plan to begin holiday shopping by the end of October, and 29% expect to start earlier than last year, according to PayPal's Holiday Shopping Survey.
  • More than half plan to shop before Thanksgiving.
  • InMarket found 66% of holiday shoppers expect to have started by October, labeling the earlier window a new "Decision Season."
  • Adtaxi's Holiday Shopping Survey found 77% of shoppers expect to maintain or increase their holiday spending even as they start earlier and stay selective about value.

The compressed December window is the practical constraint for homemade gifts. Edible gifts involve baking, cooling, packaging and labeling; body-care projects require making, testing and filling containers. Starting now turns those stages into part of the experience instead of one long deadline.

Personalization does not require perfection

Customization now reaches broadly across the gift market. Shopify's 2026 Personalized Gift Guide highlights custom artwork, monogrammed goods and personalized food and kitchen items. Mintel's Seasonal Gifting Trends research points to growing interest in distinctive, curated and personalized gifts as alternatives to predictable presents.

A homemade gift can answer that demand without professional polish. A jar with a handwritten label, a DIY coffee scrub for a coffee lover, or a batch of cookies packaged for a specific recipient can communicate more than a finished gift set, the handmade quality itself being part of the appeal.

Homemade and retail also coexist. DIY lotion bars can sit beside a purchased candle; a jar of elderberry syrup can accompany a book. The homemade element does not have to carry the entire gift, and consumers do not need to become dedicated crafters to participate.

What unites the trend is its most expensive ingredient: time. Homemade gifts can be inexpensive or elaborate, practical or sentimental, but each carries evidence that someone made something for someone else. Starting early leaves room to test recipes, make several batches and give each present the attention it deserves — work that is finished before the holidays arrive.

holiday-shoppingconsumer-trendsscreen-free-giftshomemade-giftspersonalized-gifts

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

718 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »