Puerto Rico's Thanksgiving: A Menu Built From 85% Imported Food
Puerto Rico imports 85% of its food, yet chef Giovanna Huyke rebuilds Sanguiving — the island's Thanksgiving — around fresh yuca, gandules, guava and pilón-ground adobo.

Roughly 85 percent of all food consumed in Puerto Rico is imported — a figure that shapes everything on the island's Thanksgiving table, from tinned corned beef and Vienna sausages to Spam and canned vegetables. Chef and restaurateur Giovanna Huyke, the island's leading authority on the holiday, has spent four decades trying to push that table back toward fresh, local sourcing.
Puerto Rico has celebrated Thanksgiving since the early 20th century, following the US invasion of 1898. Locally the holiday goes by several names: the formal El Día de Acción de Gracias, El Día del Pavo (Turkey Day), and most commonly Sanguiving — a phonetic borrowing islanders use to describe their instinct to Puertorriqueñizar, or "make Puerto Rican," whatever arrives from the mainland.
What does the menu look like?
The Sanguiving spread replaces mainland staples systematically. Turkey gets a garlic, lime and oregano marinade instead of pumpkin-spice rubs; gravy is built on guava rather than giblets; local winter squash calabaza stands in for pumpkin; flan replaces apple pie; and coconut water served straight from the shell replaces warm cider.
Huyke's own menu, documented in her 2004 recipe booklet Celebraciones and refined every year, includes:
- Agüeybaná stuffing — fresh grated yuca ground to a paste, combined with sofrito, ground and salt pork, annatto, herbs and aromatics, named for the Taíno chief who led the island's people at the Spanish invasion in 1493.
- Pastelón — a layered casserole of fried sweet plantains and queso fresco that Huyke says likely originated in 1950s New York, where Puerto Rican and Italian communities lived side by side and "were exposed to lasagna and mozzarella."
- Guava-glazed turkey — brined in salt, brown sugar, bay leaves, herbs and peppercorns, buttered under the skin, then brushed with rum, melted butter and guava jelly, with drippings reserved for a guava gravy.
- Ajilímojilí — a sauce of garlic, ají dulce peppers, culantro, cilantro, olive oil, vinegar and capers, drizzled over nearly every dish.
- Gandules escabèche — pigeon peas in a vinaigrette with tomatoes and avocado, a departure from arroz con gandules, the national dish.
"Our adobo goes on the turkey, and all the sides have something to do with sofrito," Huyke said. The adobo itself is a blend of garlic, onion, peppers and herbs pounded in a pilón — a wooden mortar and pestle with Taíno roots.
Why so much shelf-stable food?
Two forces drove the pantry. Puerto Ricans became US citizens, and draft eligible, in 1917 — weeks before American entry into World War I — and as many as 20,000 islanders served. Soldiers brought wartime foodways home, and government subsidies reinforced them. Meanwhile the island's agrarian economy, once built on sugar, coffee and tobacco exports, converted to industrial manufacturing, deepening import dependence. A storm-prone geography cemented the reliance on canned goods.
Huyke's father, Hector, served in the Korean War and refused instant mashed potatoes afterward — except at holidays, when her mother Alice, a trained cooking instructor, simmered yellow potatoes in cream with chicken bouillon and whipped them with butter. A garlicky version still appears on Huyke's Sanguiving table.
What does Huyke want to change?
Her stated goal is moving Puerto Rican cooking away from processed ingredients toward fresh ones — not only for health, but because fresh foods, in her view, carry more flavor and better convey the island's layered culinary history. "We have a rich and resilient food history — it came from necessity, lack, and a bounty from the land," she said, tracing the cuisine to Spanish, Indigenous Taíno and West African roots that "grew from our land and from our history, mixing every influence in our pilónes and our cauldrons."
Education remains her vehicle. A TV personality, columnist and cookbook author since the late 1980s, she mentors young chefs including Natalia Vallejo, the island's first James Beard Award winner, and auditions new Sanguiving dishes each year. "I believe every cuisine evolves," she said. "But traditions should be kept and taught. So we do not lose the roots that make us unique."
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.
722 articles


