Regulation & Food Safety

NYC Bill Would Fine Restaurants $100 Per Lobster Boiled Alive

A new NYC Council bill would fine restaurants $100 for each lobster boiled alive, mirroring bans in Switzerland, England and New Zealand. Operators say it's the wrong fight.

NYC Council aims to ban boiling live lobsters — but restaurateurs are steaming mad: ‘Laughable’
NYC Council aims to ban boiling live lobsters — but restaurateurs are steaming mad: ‘Laughable’ — AI-generated

A $100 fine per lobster. That's the price New York City restaurants could soon pay for every crustacean they drop into a pot alive, under a bill introduced Thursday in the City Council.

The proposal, sponsored by Bronx Councilman Oswald Feliz and Manhattan Councilman Harvey Epstein, would ban boiling any living crustacean — "including but not limited to lobsters and crabs" — anywhere in the five boroughs. First violations draw a warning. Every lobster boiled alive after that costs the operator $100.

The menu isn't the target. Restaurants could keep serving lobster; the bill simply requires that the animal be killed before cooking, not during it.

What does the bill actually change for operators?

In practice, it would force kitchens that currently boil or steam live shellfish to add a killing step — the approach recommended in countries with similar laws. That usually means electrical stunning or freezing, followed by a knife strike to the animal's nervous system. That's equipment, training and time on top of what operators say are already stretched margins.

"Restaurants are fighting high rents, food costs, labor costs and taxes," said Zach Erdem, a top Hamptons chef. "Now we're supposed to worry about hurting a lobster's feelings? What's next? Are we going to need permission from City Hall before we crack a crab leg?"

Erdem went further than complaining. He said he would probably scrap plans for a Manhattan restaurant over the proposal, arguing the City Council has misplaced priorities.

"I love New York. But when politicians start worrying more about lobsters than the people trying to make a living, something is seriously wrong," he said. "The lobsters might be safe, but the restaurant business is getting cooked!"

Where does the cruelty argument stand?

Feliz, defending the bill, told The Post: "Boiling an animal alive is the textbook definition of animal cruelty."

"Some argue that lobsters don't feel pain. If they don't feel pain, why do they thrash around and desperately try to escape when thrown into boiling water?" he said. "I also want to be clear: this bill does not remove lobster from the menu or prevent anyone from eating it. Everyone is completely free to enjoy as much lobster as they want."

The science is contested. Some studies suggest crustaceans have pain responses similar to mammals, which is the position animal welfare activists have pushed. Other experts argue their nervous systems resemble those of insects — simple and, on their reading, pain-free.

New York would join a global wave

The city wouldn't be first. Live-boil bans are already in force in Switzerland, New Zealand, England, Austria, Norway and large parts of Australia. In those jurisdictions, the standard method is stun first — electrically or by freezing — then a knife to the nervous system before cooking.

The New York restaurateur reaction has been blunt. "This is nuts," said Angelo Vivolo, the retired New York Italian restaurant operator. "What's next, do they want to introduce not using cow for meat or forget about prosciutto at an Italian restaurant? Fuggadaboutit!"

"It's idiocy," Vivolo said. "When it gets out to the restaurant industry they are going to be saying the same things. This regulation is absolutely insane."

A familiar, slow fight

The lobster bill isn't the only animal welfare measure on the Council's docket. A separate proposal would ban handing out live goldfish as prizes anywhere in the city.

And there's precedent for how long these fights can drag. The Council passed a foie gras ban in 2019; it has been tied up in court appeals ever since. The crustacean proposals won't come to a vote for some time.

For now, the $100-per-lobster question sits with the Council — and New York's shellfish kitchens keep boiling.

nyc-restaurant-regulationslobster-cookinganimal-welfarerestaurant-complianceproposed-legislation

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

761 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »