Development & Finance

Nine experts put historic hotel conversion economics to the test

A Hotel Designs-Lutron roundtable in Mayfair puts adaptive reuse economics first: viable room counts, the right brand, early wiring and workable community consent.

Roundtable: Layer by Layer: historic buildings as modern hotels
Roundtable: Layer by Layer: historic buildings as modern hotels — GregoryButler / pixabay

By Daniel Okafor

Nine hospitality and design specialists gathered at The Chancery Rosewood in Mayfair for a Hotel Designs roundtable with Lutron, where the first commercial test was blunt: how many hotel rooms can a historic building keep while becoming safe, functional and commercially viable?

Hotel Designs and Lutron hosted the summer forum to examine manor houses, castles and former manufacturing plants, putting operating economics ahead of nostalgia: heritage constraints, guest expectations and capital feasibility had to converge.

  • Paul Gallacher, design director at EPR Architects; Natalia Miyar, founder of Natalia Miyar; Kim Partridge, founder of Kim Partridge Interiors.
  • Nick de Klerk, associate partner and head of hotels at Purcell; Despina Kalapoda, senior director of design strategies EMEA at Marriott International; Nicolla Farry, hospitality sales manager for UK and Ireland at Lutron.
  • Jessica Morrison, design director at GA; Maria Wojtowicz, head of creative at Omnam; and Sophie Harper, editor of Hotel Designs.

What makes a historic conversion commercially workable?

Experience supplies the first instinct, Partridge said, but strong bones depend on proportion and fluid circulation, with no overlap among guest, staff and back-of-house spaces.

Wojtowicz’s team treats red flags as solvable unless municipal or third-party relationships are rigid and beyond its control. De Klerk sees common ground: officials and hotel teams generally want the building back in business.

Kalapoda framed room math as decisive: how many keys the hotel needs and how many it can afford to lose for functionality. Miyar said environmental upgrades or fire protection can consume enough volume to cut the key count and make a project untenable.

“The commercial viability is the big one. If it doesn’t stack up, we can’t do anything with it,” Gallacher said. On NoMaad London, initially planned for Hilton, uncovering more of the historic building exposed constraints that did not fit the chain. It became part of NoMaad, which changed the project as a product.

Partridge recalled a property owner who wanted Raffles; after discussions with Accor, it became a Fairmont brand following a difficult initial conversation. Gallacher’s can-do team tries to make the impossible possible and says no only when necessary; Miyar noted that nobody wants to hear no.

Early technology decisions protect capital

Farry said early involvement makes infrastructure pivotal. The discussion centered on design and wiring rather than a specified equipment replacement. When Lutron enters late, the choice becomes budget-driven because wiring may no longer be changeable. For property owners, early coordination protects capital; late entry turns building-technology specification into a tradeoff with other project costs.

Morrison said teams must collaborate early and get inventive when controls cannot go into ceilings or joinery. Farry’s standard: “The best technology is never actually seen.” Gallacher agreed that heritage conversion should hide infrastructure rather than shoehorn it into historic spaces.

Heritage and community shape the project

Partridge said limitations sometimes should stand, letting the building’s story speak instead of sanitizing its character. Miyar said developers cannot manufacture the life, energy, spirit or soul history brings. Wojtowicz warned against treating reuse as a museum relic; contemporary design must blend with the historic setting.

De Klerk called it an evolution that adds a layer to a building’s existing life. Purcell keeps heritage consultants in-house and researches each building before designing around how it works, rather than fighting the structure. He framed the work as collaboration with the original builders over time.

At Montcalm Brewery beside the Barbican, Gallacher’s team consulted the Barbican Residents Association, whose members he described as notoriously difficult, legally aware and living in a high-property-value estate. The team learned their names and listened to everything they said.

He said hotels can become important community assets when residents have another place for coffee, and that telling the story can change their opinion of a development.

Reuse starts with a carbon advantage

Gallacher said existing buildings perform better than new-build hotels from the outset when whole-life carbon is the measure. Farry said systems can use existing infrastructure, remain adaptable for future reuse and last for long service lives; she cited a public-area Lutron system installed 18 years ago that was still working.

GA’s Morrison detailed how her team completed 1 Hotel Mayfair three years ago after the client initially pursued demolition and a major architectural competition weighing mixed-use or commercial plans. The project retained a former Holiday Inn building, partnered with 1 Hotel and converted it into an understated luxury property.

Existing bay sizes and a confined site tested the designers, but the team treated building retention as the more sustainable route and worked with the brand rather than paying lip service.

Gallacher said its position opposite the Ritz suited luxury, while preserving the structure made the hotel disruptive within that market. It matched the right brand to the right building rather than imposing a predetermined concept.

De Klerk and Miyar both prefer existing buildings. Miyar linked The Chancery Rosewood’s move from American Embassy use, once surrounded by Grosvenor Square barricades, to an active, engaged square, saying the hotel contributes more than an embassy or school. Wojtowicz called the sector responsible for re-energizing old buildings.

Gallacher said extra constraints create more design problems, which he finds enjoyable; Morrison called history and narrative a gift for designers.

Narrow hallways, ancient pipework and building restrictions remain. The group’s conclusion was equally practical: roots, past custodians and period styling details create intrigue, but charm cannot be engineered.

For owners, the next test is whether early room-count, brand and wiring decisions can preserve enough keys and capital to turn heritage into a viable operating asset.

historic-hotel-conversionsconversion-economicsadaptive-reuseheritage-conservationbuilding-technology

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

694 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »