Regulation & Food Safety

AMA Backs Near-Total Ban on Engineered Stone Countertops

The AMA's 250,000-plus members now oppose high-silica engineered stone, backing California's push to ban a material that has sickened more than 680 stoneworkers.

Largest US doctors’ group supports banning countertop material linked to deadly lung disease
Largest US doctors’ group supports banning countertop material linked to deadly lung disease — wingsofcompassion / pixabay

The American Medical Association has formally opposed the manufacturing, importation, distribution, sale, fabrication and installation of high-silica engineered stone nationwide. The policy, adopted by the largest physician group in the U.S. — more than 250,000 physicians and medical students — lands as California regulators prepare a first-in-the-nation phaseout of the material.

The human toll driving the decision is already measured. More than 680 stoneworkers in California have contracted silicosis after inhaling silica dust from cutting or polishing engineered stone, also sold as artificial stone or quartz. Dozens have died, and 75 have undergone lung transplants since 2019, according to the California Department of Public Health. Most of the sick workers are Latino men who say they learned of the hazard only after feeling shortness of breath themselves.

"Workers are developing an incurable lung disease that can progress to respiratory failure and sometimes, death, often at a young age," AMA Board Member Sheila Rege, a radiation oncologist, said in a statement. "Silicosis is preventable, and the most effective way to prevent silicosis is to use safer countertop materials containing less than 1% crystalline silica with appropriate dust control measures."

What does this change for California's ban?

The AMA declaration adds medical weight to a state workplace standards board vote, expected next month, on an emergency regulation phasing out engineered stone with more than 1% crystalline silica for countertops and other surfaces. Australia banned engineered stone slabs first, in 2024. California already requires wet cutting, sophisticated masks and ventilation — but Cal/OSHA inspectors found violations at most fabrication shops they visited, and evidence shows workers get sick even at compliant shops.

The projected cost of inaction is stark. Cal/OSHA estimates that between 1,000 and 1,500 of California's roughly 5,000 countertop fabrication workers could develop silicosis within the next decade, causing roughly 285 deaths.

"This is recognition by the larger house of medicine that the material cannot be safely used," said Dr. Robert Blink, a San Francisco occupational medicine physician and former president of the Western Occupational and Environmental Medical Association. "We've certainly been trying to raise the alarm because this is a deadly epidemic that is killing people."

Blink added that the AMA resolution could push federal OSHA, other states and Congress toward regulation. Cases have already surfaced in Colorado, Florida, Illinois and Texas, though only California systematically tracks the disease in the industry.

Who's fighting the ban?

Manufacturers want the liability question answered differently. Cambria, the largest U.S.-based producer of high-silica artificial stone, has backed a bill in Congress that would immunize manufacturers and distributors from hundreds of lawsuits by sick workers. Its trade group, the International Surface Fabricators Association, has petitioned California to certify fabricators instead of restricting the material.

ISFA CEO Laurie Weber doubted a ban would help most workers, since "unlicensed, uninspected operators who cut stone unsafely today would continue to cut whatever comes next the same way."

"Silicosis is real, it is devastating and it is preventable," Weber said in a statement. "Our disagreement is not with the medicine. It is with the idea that a product ban on fabrication, by itself, will protect the people doing this work."

Lopez, a former Bay Area stoneworker who cut engineered stone for years and received a double lung transplant in March, put it more bluntly: "Health must take precedence over commercial interests." KQED is withholding his full name because he fears losing medical care if arrested by immigration authorities.

For consumers, the material is safe once installed — the exposure risk sits entirely with the fabrication workforce. With the AMA now on record, the pressure shifts to the California standards board next month, and after that to federal regulators watching whether the first state ban survives.

engineered-stonesilicosiscountertopscal-oshaworker-safety

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

692 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »