Development & Finance

Shake Shack Opens 54 Units This Year Without Eating Its Own Sales

Shake Shack's Q3 revenue rose 15.2% to $423.3M as 54 new units opened without denting same-store sales, which grew 2.5% for a fifth straight quarter. Investors took the weekend to agree.

Shake Shack bets on expansion without cannibalization
Shake Shack bets on expansion without cannibalization — OurWhiskyFoundation / pixabay

Shake Shack opened 21 locations last quarter and expects as many as 65 by year-end, and the math is starting to work for investors. Revenue rose 15.2% to $423.3 million in the quarter. Adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) climbed 16% to $62.8 million.

The numbers matter because CEO Rob Lynch has rewired the chain's growth thesis. Shake Shack was built as a special-occasion burger destination. Lynch wants an everyday one, with more units and more visits per customer.

The market spent months worrying that faster development would dilute the chain's famously high unit volumes. Those worries now look premature.

What did the quarter actually show?

Same-store sales rose 2.5% in the third quarter, with traffic up 0.8%. That was the fifth consecutive quarter of growth for both metrics. The streak proves the gains do not depend on easy year-over-year comparisons.

New openings included Charleston and Greenville, South Carolina. The company has opened 54 shops so far this year. Lynch puts the long-run ceiling at 1,500 domestic locations.

The new units are smaller performers. Lynch told investors they open at annualized volumes between $3 million and $3.5 million, below the systemwide average of roughly $4 million. They also carry lower profit margins than the existing base.

That drag is real but bounded. Management's bet is that total revenue and EBITDA growth more than offsets the somewhat lower volumes across the system.

Is new development cannibalizing old shacks?

Largely, no. "We're not building shacks in close proximity to each other," Lynch told analysts Friday, according to a transcript on the financial services site AlphaSense. The company does not open shops within 10 miles of one another, at least outside Manhattan.

The exception is delivery. A new location's delivery radius typically spans 7 miles, which can overlap with an existing shop's radius and shift some orders to the newcomer. That is the one cannibalization channel Lynch acknowledged.

The restraint is deliberate. Shake Shack opens fewer locations than most chains, and its high-volume New York units skew the system average upward. Unit economics (the per-store sales and profit picture) have always carried outsized weight in the investment case, which is why investors feared that Lynch's pace would erode profitability over time.

"That's the model going forward," Lynch said. "We're going to open 60-plus units every year. And we're going to drive revenue and EBITDA growth with new shacks. But we're also going to continue to drive comps and be productive to mitigate the short-term margin and comp implications from those new shack openings."

How did Wall Street react?

With hesitation, then conviction. The stock initially declined after Friday's earnings release, then recovered during the call. On Monday it jumped nearly 9%. The weekend apparently helped analysts sort the unit-volume question from the growth question.

The recovery still leaves ground to cover. Shares are down 4% year to date and 14% over the past 12 months.

Lynch said new locations continue to generate strong returns, which justifies their opening. The company plans to monitor development closely to confirm those returns persist.

"We are growing the number of shacks every year, and so those headwinds are going to continue to be present," he said. "We're going to continue to track them very closely to make sure they're delivering on our returns. And we feel great about the impact it's having on our revenue growth and our EBITDA growth."

The forward question is arithmetic, not sentiment: whether 60-plus openings a year at $3 million-plus volumes can keep compounding faster than the margin drag they create. Five quarters of positive traffic suggest, for now, that they can.

shake-shackrestaurant-expansionunit-economicssame-store-salesquick-service-restaurants

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

711 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »