Hotel Operations

Full-Service Hotel GMs Are Stuck at Desks Doing Clerks' Work

Owners run full-service hotels on select-service math — 33-35% GOP margins vs 40-50% — and the GM absorbs the paperwork. HVS and Newport Hospitality say the model has gone too far.

Where Did the Hotelier Go? How Full-Service GMs Became Administrators
Where Did the Hotelier Go? How Full-Service GMs Became Administrators — GregoryButler / pixabay

Full-service hotels run on roughly 2.57 labor hours per occupied room; select-service hotels need about 1.44. That gap, and the GOP margin gap behind it — roughly 33-35% versus 40-50% — explains why the general manager of a 300-room hotel with a restaurant, bar, banquets and a bell stand now spends the day reconciling deposits and chasing invoices. The industry's most senior operators say so out loud.

Newport Hospitality Group CEO Andrew Carey wrote in March 2026 that managers have been pulled for decades into administrative work "that keeps them behind a desk instead of building relationships with guests and associates." His verdict: the trend needs to be reversed.

Why did the owners change the math?

The numbers made the argument. CBRE's Trends data showed a 44.2% GOP margin (gross operating profit, the profit line most hotel contracts measure) for select-service properties in 2015, against 37.5% for all surveyed hotels. Owners and lenders asked the obvious question. They started managing full-service P&Ls to select-service targets: fewer staff, fewer outlets, fewer salaried managers.

The pandemic then licensed the cuts. During 2020 and 2021, hotels dropped daily housekeeping, closed restaurants and trimmed staff. Host Hotels CEO Jim Risoleo told investors the industry was moving toward housekeeping as opt-in rather than opt-out. Analysts said many hotels were weighing permanent reductions in cleaning and breakfast service. Operators pushed grab-and-go markets inside full-service properties — less labor, strong margins.

The opt-in rate is now measurable. At a Crescent Real Estate-affiliated hotel group, only about 34% of guests opted in to full housekeeping. UNITE HERE, the hotel workers' union, published a Park Hotels & Resorts operating-priorities list from November 2021 that included permanent reductions in full-time staffing, limited housekeeping, and eliminating or repurposing unprofitable F&B. That is a union's framing. But the priorities match what owners said publicly.

The thinking predates COVID-19. A CoStar owners' panel report quotes one owner who would lease out the restaurant entirely, and another who noted a free breakfast costs about $1.86 per guest — cheaper than running restaurants.

Where did the paperwork come from?

Centralization. Management companies and brands pulled revenue management, marketing, purchasing and accounting out of the hotel. The property still has to feed those systems. Someone must prepare deposits, code invoices, approve payables and answer every report. Increasingly that someone is the GM, because the controller, assistant GM and department heads who shared the load were cut.

HVS, in its 2026 profitability outlook, reported that GOP margins have been declining — driven by labor, brand operating standards and shared-service allocations — and advised owners to review centralized revenue management, marketing and accounting fees against the value actually delivered. The cost of centralization lands on the property. So does the work.

Contracts compound the problem. One hospitality analyst noted that many management contracts reward topline performance over GOP participation through tiered incentives, so owners can see respectable occupancy and ADR (average daily rate) growth while margins deteriorate. A HOTELS magazine analysis, summarized by Hospitality.Today, found GMs pulled into operational detail and financial oversight because fewer experienced managers sit between leadership and the frontline. Cut the layer below the GM and the work rolls uphill.

What does it cost?

The list is short and expensive:

  • The guest. A full-service rate with limited-service staffing disappoints, and the service gap is where reviews, group business and repeat loyalty leak away.
  • The team. Associates need a visible leader who coaches in real time. A GM at a desk cannot model the standard.
  • The pipeline. Future GMs trained on compliance and reporting become administrators, not hoteliers.
  • The owner. Full-service hotels earn their premium from group business, banquets and F&B. Strip those out and the property competes with select-service brands on their terms while carrying a higher cost structure.

A fair counterpoint exists. Labor, insurance, property taxes, brand fees and debt service all rose together, and ADR growth is expected to flatten. Cost control is a real duty, and some cuts — opt-in housekeeping among them — may be permanent and partly accepted by guests. The question is which costs constitute the hotel's reason for being.

Can AI return the GM to the lobby?

Carey's proposed fix is AI that handles reporting and data assembly, freeing managers for the floor. That may help. But software does not replace a laid-off controller, an assistant GM who was never hired, or a department head carrying three jobs.

The practical remedies in the source are structural, not technical: define what the GM must do personally, fund the middle layer, track floor time alongside GOP and RevPAR (revenue per available room), staff to the brand promise or reposition honestly, and hire GMs for operating strength first with back-office support attached.

The stakes are straightforward. Full-service hotels need a hotelier in the building, not just in the office — and whether ownership decides the GM's floor time is worth protecting will decide which one the industry produces.

full-service-hotelshotel-general-managershotel-staffinglabor-costsback-office-operations

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

711 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »