Ford’s Garage Weighs Rollback of 20% Service Charge After Backlash
Ford's Garage may push its Florida franchisee to change a mandatory 20% service charge at five restaurants, even as the operator reports higher server pay and year-over-year growth under the model.

A mandatory 20% service charge tested at five Florida Ford's Garage locations is now under active review, with brand president Billy Downs telling Fox News Digital the chain may push to change the program after customer pushback.
The fee is not a corporate initiative. Franchisee 23 Restaurant Services, which operates Ford's Garage restaurants across Florida, introduced the charge as part of a team service model that replaces traditional tipping. Servers and bartenders earn commissions based on sales, and the structure is designed to spread compensation more evenly to kitchen and support staff. Additional tips remain optional.
What does the charge change for diners and staff?
For customers, the model adds a fixed 20% to every check, disclosed verbally and in writing before they order. Marc Brown, president of 23 Restaurant Services, framed it as simple menu pricing. "So, to us, it's no different than just charging a higher price on the menu," he said. Guests who object can choose not to dine there.
For employees, the economics appear favorable. "Our servers in the locations that run our service charge program are making significantly higher average hourly pay than our servers and bartenders in locations that do not have it," Brown said. He added that most participating restaurants have posted year-over-year growth after running the model for multiple years.
One participating location, in Plantation near Fort Lauderdale, lists the charge as applied "in lieu of a traditional gratuity." That restaurant also adds a separate 1% entertainment fee assessed by its shopping center — money the company says is passed to the retail center and not distributed to employees.
Why is the brand reconsidering?
Downs, who oversees a chain founded in Fort Myers in 2012 and now spanning 36 restaurants across nine states, said the experiment was designed to test whether a different compensation model could contain costs for guests while still rewarding servers. "It certainly was a test to see if this can help keep the cost down to the consumer, as well as reward the server," he said.
The results have been mixed. "There's been some big wins, and there's been consumers that just do not want to pay a service charge," Downs said. "But the biggest pushback is people don't want to have a mandated service charge, and I get it. You know, I'm not sure I want it either in certain times."
He indicated the brand is leaning toward intervention. "I think that we need to listen to the consumer on those things, to be honest with you," Downs said. "So, we are, and we may be encouraging a change to that program."
The test runs against a backdrop of rising labor costs and shifting tipped minimum wage rules that are pushing operators nationwide to experiment with service charges, higher menu prices or no-tipping models.
Does the model kill service incentives?
Brown rejected the argument that a guaranteed commission removes the motivation to perform. Employees are expected to "provide great service to every guest regardless of what they expect to get in terms of additional tip," he said. He also noted the criticism comes from a relatively small share of diners, and said most guests are not bothered "because they like the Ford's Garage experience."
The chain's value positioning raises the stakes of any pricing change. Downs said Ford's Garage has prioritized affordability, with an average check of about $26 and weekday value meals starting at $10.99. Consistent service, he argued, is the best defense against fee fatigue: "If you give great service all the time, that can help to eliminate problems."
No timeline has been set. "We have not made any decisions, but we talk about it regularly," Brown said — leaving the five-location test running while the brand and its largest Florida franchisee weigh whether a commission model can survive at a chain built on a $26 check.
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.
718 articles


