Hotel Operations

U.S. Hotels Keep a Shrinking Slice of Every Guest Dollar

Hotels lost $2.3 billion in kept revenue last year as expense growth of 5–10% outruns RevPAR gains, pushing Marriott and others toward conversions over new builds.

U.S. Hotels Are Keeping Less and Less of Every Guest Dollar
U.S. Hotels Are Keeping Less and Less of Every Guest Dollar — GregoryButler / pixabay

Hotels lost $2.3 billion in kept revenue last year as their share of guest spending — what Kalibri calls "revenue capture" — fell 1.11 percentage points. Hold that share flat, and U.S. hotel asset values would sit nearly $30 billion higher.

That's the core math Cindy Estis Green, CEO and co-founder of the data firm Kalibri, laid out at the Skift Commerce Summit. Her diagnosis: labor, insurance, taxes, debt service, renovation costs, utilities, and customer acquisition costs have all been rising faster than average room rates in recent years.

The squeeze isn't easing. Kalibri expects expenses to grow 5% to 10% a year over the next few years, while RevPAR growth runs somewhere between flat and 3%. Roughly speaking, for every extra dollar a hotel brings in the door, costs are climbing fast enough to claim most of it.

Is hotel business actually bad right now?

No — and that's what makes the trend unsettling. "Business is great right now," said Tyler Morse, chairman and CEO of MCR, one of the country's largest hotel owners. U.S. RevPAR is forecast to rise 4.4% this year, according to CoStar and Tourism Economics, after slipping 0.3% last year.

The problem is the gap between the top line and the owner's pocket. Strong revenue years are still producing weaker owner economics because the cost stack compounds faster than rates.

What does this mean for new construction?

New builds are getting harder to justify. Morse put construction costs up about 50% in five years. A stick-built Home2 Suites now runs about $250,000 a key — math that doesn't pencil without a $200 average daily rate.

So growth is shifting to conversions. More than 40% of Marriott's openings in the first nine months of this year were conversions of existing buildings, and new-build hotel starts in the U.S. and Canada remain below pre-pandemic levels.

Where is pricing power still working?

Luxury is pulling away from the rest of the market. Luxury chains raised rates 9% in the third quarter, against just 1% for budget properties. The backdrop: the number of U.S. ultra-wealthy individuals has more than doubled in inflation-adjusted terms since 2005, giving the top of the market a customer base that can absorb the increases.

Budget and midscale operators don't have that cushion, which sharpens the divide in owner returns across segments.

Who pays for the next wave of distribution costs?

Both executives pointed to AI search as the next pressure point on customer acquisition. Morse predicted AI search would develop paid-placement economics similar to Google's, with one dominant player controlling the toll.

Estis Green's answer to who absorbs that cost was blunt: it's always the owner who ends up paying. As AI-driven booking channels mature, expect acquisition costs — already outpacing room-rate growth — to take another bite out of revenue capture. Absent cost relief or a rate breakout in luxury, the gap between guest spending and owner earnings looks set to widen again next year.

hotel-profitabilityrevenue-captureoperating-costshotel-conversionsai-driven-distribution

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

757 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »