Restaurant Operations

Two-Thirds of Checks Mix Both Menus: Inside Dine's Dual-Brand Play

Two-thirds of checks at Dine's 60 dual-brand Applebee's-IHOP restaurants mix both menus, and CEO John Peyton sees room for roughly 900 more over the next decade.

5 Lessons from John Peyton on Dine’s Dual-Brand Bet
5 Lessons from John Peyton on Dine’s Dual-Brand Bet — RealAKP / pixabay

Two-thirds of checks at Dine Brands' dual-brand restaurants include items from both the Applebee's and IHOP menus — a figure CEO John Peyton says validates a concept nobody asked the company to build.

Dine now runs 60 combined Applebee's-IHOP locations, with more in development and what Peyton frames as an opportunity for roughly 900 dual-brand restaurants over the next decade. Speaking on FSR's Restaurant Innovator podcast, he laid out the economics and operating lessons behind a format that grew from international experimentation into a U.S. development pipeline, entirely through franchisees willing to convert existing buildings before every detail was settled.

Why pair breakfast strength with dinner strength?

The logic starts with dayparts, not brand affinity. IHOP brings a dominant breakfast business and a historically weak dinner daypart. Applebee's owns the afternoon and evening but never served breakfast. Put them in one building, and each brand picks up an occasion it couldn't win alone.

That matters in a high-cost environment. Peyton frames adding an entire daypart as a fundamentally different growth proposition than fighting for another incremental visit. Most dual-brand locations are conversions, which lets franchisees spread unchanged fixed costs across more sales.

"That incremental revenue flows at a higher margin than the original restaurant because the fixed costs remain the same," he says. In plain terms: the rent, the shell, and much of the equipment were already paid for. The breakfast or dinner traffic stacked on top is nearly pure contribution.

How do you research something customers can't picture?

Peyton is blunt that a focus group would have struggled to evaluate a shared Applebee's-IHOP experience sight unseen. Dine wasn't flying blind — international operators had already opened dual-brand restaurants, and Peyton visited locations before bringing the concept stateside — but translating that evidence into a U.S. format required franchisees who'd open before the playbook was finished.

"We had conversations with the first franchisees that the concept you open is not going to necessarily be the concept in two years, and together we're going to refine it and tweak it," Peyton says. "And so we went big and we went all in."

The research followed the openings rather than replacing them. With restaurants running, Dine could ask guests directly what worked. One early finding: guests largely don't care which brand's side of the room they sit on, provided they can order from both menus.

"One of the definitions of innovation is giving the consumer something they didn't know they wanted," Peyton says.

What does the combined menu do to kitchen complexity?

Overseas dual-brand sites had essentially merged both menus. The U.S. team took a different route, streamlining the offering so the total item count stays in line with a single brand's menu. Overlapping products went through a comparison process — the resulting burger, for instance, pairs an Applebee's patty build with an IHOP bun.

Menu editing doesn't erase the learning curve. Applebee's teams must absorb IHOP's weekend breakfast crush.

"There's nothing that you can really say to prepare them for what happens on Saturday and Sunday morning at an IHOP," Peyton says. "No one orders their pancakes and eggs the same way."

IHOP franchisees face the mirror-image challenge: many have never run a bar, which Peyton calls "the heartbeat and the cultural hub of the restaurant," with bartenders building regulars and supporting servers. The combined menu also carries mashup items exclusive to dual-brand locations — Peyton's favorite is the buffalo chicken omelet, Applebee's boneless wings folded into an IHOP omelet.

Who actually runs the project?

Peyton didn't hand the rollout to staff juggling day jobs. Dine pulled roughly a dozen people into a dedicated team with a mandate to move fast.

"It was no one's part-time job," he says. "It was a dedicated team to just work on that, and they had permission to break things."

He also refused the slow path — no multi-year study, no one or two pilot restaurants followed by a year of waiting. Dine signed development-oriented, risk-taking franchisees and opened the first 10 or 12 units immediately. "If we hadn't done that, we wouldn't be having this conversation today," Peyton says.

Is this a third brand?

No — and Peyton is emphatic about keeping it that way.

"We have our red brand, we have our blue brand," he says. "We haven't created a purple brand."

The format only works if Applebee's and IHOP remain compelling individually, through their own menus, marketing, and identities. Even at 900 potential dual-brand sites over a decade, Peyton expects standalone locations to far outnumber the combinations.

The discipline extends to the P&L. Guests get one check, but Dine splits the revenue between the two brands so it can report separate comparable sales — and even mashup items get allocated so, in Peyton's words, "everyone gets their fair share."

"We've created an experience where guests can enjoy Applebee's and IHOP in the same location at the same time, and the dual brands will only be as strong as Applebee's and IHOP are as individual brands," he says. With 60 units open and a conversion model that monetizes existing real estate, the question for the next decade is how fast franchisees convert that 900-unit ceiling into signings.

dual-brand-restaurantsfranchise-developmentmenu-engineeringdaypart-strategyrestaurant-conversions

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

694 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »