Regulation & Food Safety

Retailers Kept $235 Billion From Debit Fee Caps, Economists Say

Economists estimate large retailers kept $235 billion from the Durbin debit fee cap; over 98% of businesses did not lower prices, a Fed-cited survey found.

Economists Say Retailers Kept $235 Billion From Debit Fee Caps Instead of Cutting Prices
Economists Say Retailers Kept $235 Billion From Debit Fee Caps Instead of Cutting Prices — AI-generated

Fifteen years after Congress capped debit card interchange fees, a new economic analysis estimates that large retailers kept $235 billion in profits rather than cutting prices for consumers. Economists Robert Shapiro and Michael Strain conducted the analysis, which marks the most aggressive accounting to date of what happened to the savings promised under the Durbin Amendment.

The core finding is blunt. A Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond survey cited in the report found that more than 98 percent of businesses either kept prices unchanged or raised them after the cap took effect. Retail industry groups had told Congress the opposite would happen when the amendment was debated.

The National Restaurant Association said at the time that the reform would "benefit consumers in the form of lower prices." A National Retail Federation executive said merchants were prepared to pass savings along through "discounts and other benefits." The Food Marketing Institute predicted "significant savings" for consumers.

How the money was distributed

The gains concentrated at the top of the retail sector. The analysis found that roughly 150 of the largest national and regional retail chains captured 42.7 percent of total savings from the fee cap — about $101.9 billion.

At the other end, more than 2.4 million neighborhood retailers with under $1 million in annual sales received just 1.7 percent of total savings, averaging roughly $120 per business per year.

What does this change for restaurants and small operators?

The report also found the cap raised costs on low-dollar debit transactions — the frequent, small purchases that drive traffic at coffee shops, convenience stores and quick-service restaurants. For operators in those segments, interchange economics on a $4 transaction got worse, not better, after the mandate.

A bank-funded study enters the credit-card fight

Context matters here. The Electronic Payments Coalition, a trade group representing banks and payment card networks, published the analysis as sponsored content. The coalition has a direct financial stake in blocking new interchange-fee mandates now pending in Congress and in state legislatures, and it has funded research and advocacy supporting its position throughout the debate.

The coalition's executive chairman, Richard Hunt, framed the findings as a credibility test for retailers seeking new mandates.

"The corporate megastores have a credibility problem," Hunt said. "They promised American families lower prices and instead pocketed $235 billion. Fifteen years later, hardworking Americans are still waiting for their money, while these same megastores are back in Washington asking Congress to do it all over again with credit cards."

Retail industry groups that lobbied for the original debit cap have not responded to the new analysis. Both sides of the long-running fight — retailers and the financial industry — carry significant financial interests in any new legislation, and each has funded work supporting its own position.

The coalition is urging Congress to reject proposed caps on credit card fees, arguing that the Durbin Amendment's track record undercuts retailers' renewed promises that consumers and small businesses would benefit this time.

debit-card-interchangepayment-processing-feesdurbin-amendmentrestaurant-operating-costsretail-economics

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

785 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »