Restaurant Traffic Down 21% Since 2018 as Deals Stall, RFDC Panelists Say
Traffic is down 21% since 2018 and private equity has pulled back, but check growth and customer-base expansion offer operators a path forward.
Restaurant industry traffic has fallen 21% since 2018, and same-store sales for 2025 are tracking up just 1.7% — a gain driven almost entirely by average check, not visits. Victor Fernandez, chief insights officer with Black Box Intelligence, delivered those numbers at the Restaurant Finance and Development Conference in Las Vegas, a three-day event that gathers operators and the companies that finance them.
The 1.7% figure, Fernandez said, "actually isn't that bad." It beats 2024 and it beats 2025's broader trend line. But the composition matters for operators: check growth is doing all the work while traffic keeps shrinking. "That's a lot," Fernandez said of the cumulative 21% decline, noting the average brand "has lost a lot of its same-store traffic." His diagnosis is structural — the industry has expanded well beyond consumer demand.
Why aren't restaurant deals getting done?
Mergers and acquisitions are in a holding pattern. Franchisors can still find buyers because the market values their low cost of capital and more predictable cash flow. Deals for restaurant companies more broadly are struggling to close, and private equity is the reason.
"Fewer private-equity firms have been interested in the restaurant space because they're getting outsized gains in other areas," said Cristin O'Hara, head of restaurants for Bank of America.
Some firms are staying out not by choice but by constraint. Their portfolios are already full of restaurant assets they cannot exit at acceptable valuations.
"Investors that were so active in the market in 2018, 2019, their portfolios are chock full of brands," said Ashish Seth, founder of Harrington Park Advisors. "They can't exit for one reason or the other. Maybe it's performance. Maybe it's not the valuation they want. So 50%, 60% of the buyer base has just evaporated."
A few buyers remain active — Savory Fund and Garnett Station Partners, for example — but they do not make up the difference, Seth said. Deals are still closing for strong operators and strong brands, provided sellers are "realistic" about the valuations they can expect.
What does 'value' mean now?
Conference presenters pushed chains to redefine value away from price alone. Consumers now weigh what they get for the price more heavily than the price itself, and chains are adjusting accordingly — customers want better food and service and will pay more for them, because they dine out less often and want the occasion to be worth it.
"It's no longer just product. It's not just price point. It's experience and that includes QSR," said Revenue Management Solutions CMO Jana Zschieschang. Her margin prescription: get precise on pricing down to individual markets or locations. Beverages and snacks, she added, remain the biggest traffic and occasion-driving opportunities — a menu-engineering point, not just a taste trend.
Who is the competition now?
The competitive set keeps widening beyond other restaurants. Rich Shank, senior principal with Technomic, said convenience stores now compete directly with fast-food chains like McDonald's. R.J. Hottovy, head of analytical research with Placer.ai, flagged supermarkets as well, since consumers grew comfortable dining at home during the pandemic. Independent restaurants are also gaining, on the strength of a better value proposition and higher perceived quality.
More customers or more frequency?
Loyalty programs and mobile apps are built to squeeze more visits from existing customers. Chris O'Cull, analyst with Baird, used data to challenge that premise. His analysis covered 335 million visits across 1,260 restaurants and eight chains, and found that visit frequency barely changes and depends on the concept, not the marketing.
"People visit a coffee shop once a day because they do caffeine daily. People may visit a polished casual-dining restaurant a few times a year to celebrate special occasions," O'Cull said. "So frequency does not vary by segment."
The practical conclusion: grow the customer base, not the visit rate. Chili's proves the point. The chain grew its customer count by roughly 17% since 2017 — and total visits grew by the same proportion. "Traffic largely tracks the size of your customer base," O'Cull said.
For operators weighing where to spend in 2026, the RFDC takeaways point one direction: acquisition of new customers, experience-led value and location-level pricing will matter more than discount depth — while sellers heading to market should calibrate valuations to a buyer pool that is roughly half its former size.
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.
718 articles


