Staffing & Workforce

NYC 'Delivery Protection Act' Would Eliminate 7,000 Jobs, Critics Warn

NYC's Delivery Protection Act would bar Amazon's delivery subcontractors, cutting 7,000 jobs at up to $24.75 an hour, former sponsor Phil Wong and Urban League warn.

‘Delivery Protection Act’ only protects the Teamsters union
‘Delivery Protection Act’ only protects the Teamsters union — 15675001 / pixabay

New York City's proposed Delivery Protection Act would eliminate roughly 7,000 delivery and warehouse jobs, according to opponents who now include a former sponsor of the bill itself.

The legislation, now before the City Council, would bar private-sector companies from using last-mile-delivery subcontractors. Its primary target is Amazon. Opponents of the measure argue the ban would eliminate about 5,000 delivery positions, plus another 2,000 jobs if Amazon responds by closing its New York City warehouses rather than restructuring its delivery model.

At stake is a network of local delivery operators that pay up to $24.75 an hour, according to the bill's critics, along with health benefits, 401(k) matches and paid vacation.

Who backs the bill — and why opponents say the logic fails

The Teamsters union supports the measure, and supporters including Councilwoman Tiffany Cabán and Mayor Zohran Mamdani have framed it as a check on Amazon's labor practices.

One subcontractor, DashWave Delivery, has raised a structural objection: several city agencies — the Department of Homeless Services, the Department for the Aging and the Department of Transportation — rely on their own contractors for meal delivery, construction hauling and similar work. If contracting out delivery is permissible for the city itself, opponents argue, the bill is less about the practice than about which workers control the private market.

Opponents also warn of downstream pricing effects. Restructuring last-mile delivery away from subcontractors would raise operating costs, they say, costs that would ultimately land on New York consumers already straining under affordability pressures.

What does the bill change for local operators?

The businesses in the crosshairs are largely minority-owned, small, independent delivery companies, according to the source reporting on the dispute. Owners built these operations from scratch, and the jobs they provide are far from low-wage work, opponents say — hence the $24.75-per-hour figure and full benefits packages they cite as evidence.

The economic argument has already moved votes. Councilman Phil Wong, a Queens Democrat, switched from sponsoring the bill to opposing it after weighing the projected job losses.

National Urban League President Marc Morial has warned that the measure would deal a devastating blow to "black and brown New Yorkers."

Council Speaker Julie Menin, who has not taken a hard position against the bill, is working to amend the Delivery Protection Act into a less destructive form, according to the source — a signal that leadership recognizes the cost projections but is not prepared to withdraw the legislation outright.

The path forward

The bill remains before the City Council with no final vote scheduled in the source material. Opponents, including Wong and outside groups such as the National Urban League, are pushing to defeat it entirely rather than amend it, arguing that any version that restricts subcontracted delivery will cost jobs and raise prices for average New Yorkers. Whether Menin's amendments can satisfy labor backers while softening the projected 7,000-job impact will determine the bill's fate in the coming council sessions.

delivery-workerslast-mile-deliveryamazonnew-york-citylabor-policy

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.

785 articles

Pairings

« Previous articleNext article »