63.4% of Independent Hotel Bookups Still Go to OTAs Despite a Decade of Tech Spend
Independent hotels sent 63.4% of 2025 bookings to OTAs, per Cloudbeds. A TNEWs opinion piece argues a decade of fragmented tech spend failed, and AI offers a reset chance.

Independent hotels handed 63.4% of their bookings to online travel agencies in 2025, according to Cloudbeds. That figure anchors a provocative opinion piece, originally published in Portugal by TNEWs, which argues the hotel industry has spent a decade buying technology without a strategy and now faces the same risk with artificial intelligence.
The author borrows a medical metaphor. In medicine, "polypharmacy" describes a patient who regularly takes five or more medications prescribed by different specialists. No single doctor errs. The pathology lies in the accumulated list and the absence of an integrated view of treatment.
How did hotel tech stacks reach this point?
The industry arrived at a similar condition, the piece argues. In 2016, the conversation covered websites, booking engines and channel managers, and not every hotel owned the full set. Today that trio has grown into a long list: urgent messaging, chatbots, CRM, revenue management systems, email tools, price comparison tools, reputation management platforms, mobile apps and loyalty programmes.
None of these is expensive alone. Together they form what the author calls a budgetary snowball effect, with hotels swept into cumulative spending that no single line item justifies.
Vendors keep promising the same outcomes: reduced dependence on OTAs, improved conversion and more direct bookings. Where factual evidence runs thin, the fallback argument is that guests simply "expect these things." The piece does not name vendors, and it does not break down what hotels spend in dollars or euros. That absence is itself part of the argument — the industry lacks the integrated view needed to measure what any of this costs or returns.
What do the numbers actually show?
The results are blunt. Conversion rates have held around 2% since 2012, despite a decade of conversion-enhancing products. Consumers have also caught on. A Twilio study cited in the piece found 70% of consumers distrust countdown timers and "last chance" warnings, and 65% avoid brands that use them.
One figure stands above the rest. Only 20% of industry professionals believe their technology infrastructure is fit for purpose, according to a survey by the Hospitality Women's Innovation Council. Four out of five, in other words, think the stack they built does not do the job.
The piece skips some context. It offers no breakdown between company-operated and franchised properties, no market-by-market data and no cost figures for the tools it lists. Readers must take the 63.4% OTA share and the 20% confidence figure on the sources' authority.
Is AI the fix or a repeat of the pattern?
Artificial intelligence now confronts hotels with more solutions and more decisions. The risk, the author warns, is repetition: fragmented investment in small tools chasing a problem list that grows as fast as the solutions themselves.
The standard prescription — integration — gets short shrift. "Integrating twelve tools does not create a strategy; it simply creates twelve connected tools." The comparison is deliberate. It is like treating drug interactions by prescribing yet another drug.
The author's proposed test for any new system shifts the question. Not "What does it do?" but "Which part of my commercial strategy does it serve?" Commercial pressure will be intense, the piece concedes, and so will the fear of being left behind — a candid admission that operators may not have the discipline the argument requires.
What does 'de-prescribing' mean for hotels?
Medicine has an answer to polypharmacy called "de-prescribing": reviewing the medication list periodically and removing what is no longer needed. It sounds simple. It is not. Nobody complains when a medication is added. Removing one requires an explanation.
Hotels will meet the same resistance, the author argues. Not every hotel needs a loyalty programme. Not every hotel needs an RMS. Many conversion tools could disappear unnoticed — and the tell is the metric they report. "When a solution cannot tell you how many bookings it generated, it tells you how many bookings it influenced."
The closing counsel is a sequence, not a slogan: decide what kind of hotel you want to be, then choose the tools. Digitise, personalise, connect, in that order. Review the list from time to time and cut what no longer earns its place. Whether operators can execute that discipline under AI-era sales pressure is the question the piece leaves open, and the one that will decide whether this wave differs from the last.
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering technology and product news in Restaurant and hotel operations at The Pass Brief.
712 articles


